The credit manager of an Akron-based company asks: “One of our commercial accounts is pretty far behind in paying on our invoices. Another vendor approached me and asked me to join in signing an involuntary bankruptcy petition. Is there any legal risk in doing this?”
In a word, yes. If an involuntary bankruptcy petition is dismissed without the debtor’s consent for any reason other than abstention of the court, Bankruptcy Code § 303(i) provides that the debtor may have judgment against the petitioning creditors for its costs, including reasonable attorneys’ fees.
Moreover, if the court determines that the petitioners, or any one of them, filed the petition in bad faith, the debtor may also have a claim for any actual damages caused by the filing and for punitive damages. Actual damages could include harm to the reputation of the debtor’s business, lost profits, and loss of earning capacity; damages that can often be quite costly. Additionally, creditors generally cannot set off these damages against any debts that the debtor owes to the creditor.
Courts award these fees to discourage creditors from using the involuntary bankruptcy process improperly—thus prospective petitioning creditors should ensure that their filing has merit and should avoid filing to gain any improper advantage or to harass the debtor. Because involuntary bankruptcy proceedings often seriously disrupt the debtor’s business, courts do not hesitate to impose costs, fees, and damage awards on a creditor that files improperly. Essentially, a creditor should make sure that its involuntary petition serves some legitimate purpose before filing.
In most cases, the filing of an involuntary bankruptcy petition, while a powerful collection tool, also involves the assumption of a calculated risk by the petitioning creditors. For this reason, and with due regard for the fact that time is often of the essence in involuntary bankruptcy cases, prospective petitioning creditors should appreciate that the decision to go forward does expose them to potential liability that would not be a factor if recourse were limited to their state law alternatives. Therefore, before filing or agreeing to sign an involuntary bankruptcy petition, a creditor should carefully balance the risk of a possibly improper filing against the benefits of the involuntary bankruptcy process.
[Editors’ Note: this is part of our irregular series in which we answer readers’ questions. If you have a question, submit it to [email protected] and we will try to answer it. For more information on involuntary bankruptcy, please see Getting Over the Scariness of Filing an Involuntary Bankruptcy Petition.
This 90 Second Lesson is based, in substantial part, in material reprinted from Commercial Bankruptcy Litigation 2d and Strategic Alternatives for and Against Distressed Businesses, with permission of Thomson Reuters. For more information about these publications, please visit www.legalsolutions.com.
To learn more about this and related topics, you may want to attend the following webinars: Bad Debtor Owes Me Money! and What to Expect and Do When Your Debtor Becomes Insolvent.]
©All Rights Reserved. April, 2020. DailyDACTM, LLC
The editors and editorial board of DailyDAC include preeminent restructuring and insolvency professionals, journalists, and editors. They are devoted to providing reliable and plain English education and deal intelligence about assignments, corporate bankruptcy, receiverships, out-of-court workouts and similar topics.
90 Second Lesson: First Step Before Buying a Distressed Business
90 Second Lesson: Selling Collateral in a 363 Sale vs Article 9 Sale
Bankruptcy Considerations in a Collections Action
Getting Over the Scariness of Filing an Involuntary Bankruptcy Petition
When to Request Relief from the Automatic Stay
File Early and Often: Filing and Amending Claims in a Bankruptcy Case
Please log in again. The login page will open in a new tab. After logging in you can close it and return to this page.
Subscribe to Our FREE Newsletter!
Get weekly updates with the latest bankruptcy articles and opportunistic deals.